Question

...
Shaun

How would you characterise the fallacies in this statement: "If prisoners receive free meals, why don't students- our future doctors, artists, engineers, etc.- also get free meals?

asked on Thursday, Oct 10, 2019 06:03:03 AM by Shaun

Top Categories Suggested by Community

Comments

Want to get notified of all questions as they are asked? Update your mail preferences and turn on "Instant Notification."

Eat Meat... Or Don't.

Roughly 95% of Americans don’t appear to have an ethical problem with animals being killed for food, yet all of us would have a serious problem with humans being killed for food. What does an animal lack that a human has that justifies killing the animal for food but not the human?

As you start to list properties that the animal lacks to justify eating them, you begin to realize that some humans also lack those properties, yet we don’t eat those humans. Is this logical proof that killing and eating animals for food is immoral? Don’t put away your steak knife just yet.

In Eat Meat… Or Don’t, we examine the moral arguments for and against eating meat with both philosophical and scientific rigor. This book is not about pushing some ideological agenda; it’s ultimately a book about critical thinking.

Get 20% off this book and all Bo's books*. Use the promotion code: websiteusers

* This is for the author's bookstore only. Applies to autographed hardcover, audiobook, and ebook.

Get the Book

Answers

...
Bo Bennett, PhD
0
We can reasonably say that there is an implied analogy here: prisoners are like other groups. It is a (very) weak analogy because prisoners are under the care of the another group (state, federal govt, etc) while they are prisoners and don't have the ability to earn money for food (unless given the opportunity). I am not an expert on the prison system, but I believe prisoners do work and get compensated very little financially, which might mean they are not getting "free meals," in which case this would also be an example of begging the question .
answered on Thursday, Oct 10, 2019 06:12:40 AM by Bo Bennett, PhD

Comments

...
boniaditya
0
Prisoners don't receive free meals, they are made to work.
They are also made to work on themselves. These prisoners are also working for us, by not being in the society they are in fact, not doing harm, i.e. no crime, consider it a tax that you pay for preventing the greater loss. They don't get to choose the food they eat, the quality of the food or the type of food and at what time they get to eat. All of these are determined by the authorities.

So do you wish to feed these students, doctors, engineers, and doctors, the food they don't wish to eat, at the time they don't want to eat and at quality standards prescribed by the authorities?

This 1984 all over again, longing for Big Brother aren't we?
answered on Thursday, Oct 10, 2019 10:56:07 AM by boniaditya

Comments

...
skips777
0
If prisoners don't pay for toilet paper, why do students, doctors, me, you, etc. have to? Prisoners get free room and board....etc. Prisoners are a group like any other, false analogy fallacy.
answered on Friday, Oct 11, 2019 02:06:26 AM by skips777

Comments

...
0
janeman writes:

Thanks for the information

posted on Thursday, Jul 30, 2020 11:55:56 AM