Question

...
Avery

Is there a logical fallacy? Or fallacies?

I read the following (possibly fallacious) sentences in The Handmaid's Tale

"Men were not just going to go away, I said. You couldn't just ignore them.

That's like saying you should go out and catch syphilis merely because it exists, Moira said. 

Are you calling Luke a social disease? I said."

asked on Wednesday, Nov 27, 2024 12:48:05 AM by Avery

Top Categories Suggested by Community

Comments

Want to get notified of all questions as they are asked? Update your mail preferences and turn on "Instant Notification."

Uncomfortable Ideas: Facts don't care about feelings. Science isn't concerned about sensibilities. And reality couldn't care less about rage.

This is a book about uncomfortable ideas—the reasons we avoid them, the reasons we shouldn’t, and discussion of dozens of examples that might infuriate you, offend you, or at least make you uncomfortable.

Many of our ideas about the world are based more on feelings than facts, sensibilities than science, and rage than reality. We gravitate toward ideas that make us feel comfortable in areas such as religion, politics, philosophy, social justice, love and sex, humanity, and morality. We avoid ideas that make us feel uncomfortable. This avoidance is a largely unconscious process that affects our judgment and gets in the way of our ability to reach rational and reasonable conclusions. By understanding how our mind works in this area, we can start embracing uncomfortable ideas and be better informed, be more understanding of others, and make better decisions in all areas of life.

Get 20% off this book and all Bo's books*. Use the promotion code: websiteusers

* This is for the author's bookstore only. Applies to autographed hardcover, audiobook, and ebook.

Get the Book

Answers

...
AI Fallacy Master
0
Yes, the exchange contains several logical fallacies and examples of poor reasoning:

1. **False Analogy**: Moira's response draws a comparison between men and syphilis, implying that engaging with men is equivalent to willingly contracting a disease. This analogy is flawed because the two scenarios are not comparable in terms of intent or consequence. The analogy falsely equates a social interaction (acknowledging the existence of men) with a health risk (contracting a disease), which is a misleading comparison.

2. **Strawman Fallacy**: Moira's argument can be seen as a strawman because it misrepresents the original statement. The initial point was about the necessity of acknowledging men's existence, not about seeking out harmful experiences. By likening the situation to contracting a disease, Moira does not address the actual claim, thereby setting up and attacking a weaker version of the argument.

3. **Loaded Question**: The question "Are you calling Luke a social disease?" introduces an assumption that the speaker is maligning Luke by equating him to a disease. This question is loaded because it imposes a negative interpretation and presupposes that the speaker made such a claim without evidence. It's a diversion that shifts the conversation from discussing men's societal roles to defending a particular individual.

These fallacies illustrate the use of faulty reasoning to sidestep the initial point about the necessity of engaging with men in society.
answered on Wednesday, Nov 27, 2024 12:48:29 AM by AI Fallacy Master

AI Fallacy Master Suggested These Categories

Comments