← Back to archive

What kind of fallacy involved lying about your political affiliations or being dishonest

Historical archive only. New interaction is disabled.

Original Question

Is this a logic fallacy? Reminding or Telling people your very liberal or Conservative when faced with criticism but then on all talking points or political views you lean towards the opposite way. I don’t know why I’m so hung up on this but it seems like an odd way too deflect criticism. Tim pool rings a bell. He is incredibly disingenuous. I’ve seen some white Supremest use this argument when called out for Racism. “I’m not a racist or a Nazi I support the welfare state and universal healthcare and I support gay marriage”. Seems like a Red herring too call your self a progressive or liberal when ever facing pushback. Like why not just identify with your political ideology why lie. 

Answers

2

I’ve seen some white Supremest use this argument when called out for Racism. “I’m not a racist or a Nazi I support the welfare state and universal healthcare and I support gay marriage”.



This is effectively trying to deny an allegation by making irrelevant references to unrelated topics.


Example:


Chris: [obviously racist language]


Daisy: That's disgusting and racist. 


Chris: I'm not racist at all! I support gay marriage and all that progressive stuff?


Firstly, Daisy was calling out Chris for making a blatantly racist comment. He can't defend himself by saying he supports gay marriage, for example, because no one asked about it. To suggest that one cannot be racist because they have a progressive view on a topic unrelated to racism is a non sequitur. Second, if Chris is lying, then the implicit argument is even more fallacious.


Daisy shouldn't, in this case, get hung up on whether Chris is telling the truth or not. She should keep pressing him on his crass, racist comment. To allow herself to be distracted by the claim would make her complicit in fallacious reasoning, too.

This very strongly depends on the context, let me explain.


To clarify, Lying is not a logical fallacy, but just a factual error.


So if someone is being dishonest, just call them a liar and give a reason for it.


So if they just say, "I am a nazi" but seconds later imply things that a nazi doesn't believe but rather would oppose then this would just be a shift of their own narrative.


Knowing that they deflect being one thing for obvious reasons shouldn't be too confusing.


 

Logically Fallacious book by Bo Bennett

Want the full book?

Get the complete guide to logical fallacies by Bo Bennett.

Buy the Book

Master Logical Fallacies Online

Take the Virversity course and sharpen your reasoning skills with structured lessons.

View Online Course