5 answers |
Is this a non-sequiturI saw this argument floating on reddit and wanted to know whether it commits the non-sequitur fallacy or not 1. Affirmative action is racist against Asians because it creates unfairness to them based on their race. 2. Asian Americans who support af... |
5 answers |
Hate speech argument fallacy?I can't quite put my finger on it but I can't help but think this argumentative statement is fallacious: Hate speech cannot be made illegal in a consistent way: outlawing hate speech would be an expression of hatred towards hate speech, wh... |
4 answers |
If you do X correctly you will never make a mistake.One of my jobs is operating a wood chipper. Sometimes it gets clogged and takes an hour of painstaking work to unclog. My boss told me that if I fed branches into the chipper correctly it would never get clogged. This mostly sounds... |
3 answers |
AbortionI think the current understanding of "my body, my choice" is misplaced. Pregnancy is not a choice, it is one of the possible consequences of choosing to have sex. "My body, my choice" should be applied to the choice of having sex. What ... |
2 answers |
Does this come off as a slothful induction?From here : “National sex education standards right now for K-3 say that gender ideology, that those children need to know by third grade that you can be a boy or a girl, neither or both,” Descovich said. “That is very concerning... |
1 answers |
What is causal argument |
2 answers |
Looking for examples of the slippery slope fallacyHey All, I'm making a resource for high school students to learn about the slippery slope fallacy and I'm looking for some real-life examples to use such as interviews, online articles or videos. Since I'm trying to make it broadly accessible, I'd ... |
2 answers |
Appeal to Nature Fallacy?"Black Americans should be able to wear their natural hair in the workplace because it grows out of their scalp." i.e. it's natural. If this is a fallacy, would it be better to propose that there's often a double standard in the workplace. Ex... |
0 answers |
Is this moving the goalpostsFrom here : At, around 15:31 James agrees with Dave (yikes, agreeing with at T R A N S P H O B E, kinda transphobic, James) that gender and sex are facts and troons don't have eggs, periods, and can't give birth. & Women don't have periods/ca... |
0 answers |
Are “Ought” statements automatically dubious when used in Non-Evaluative StatementsI understand this is the Is-Ought Problem and I’ll give what I think is an example. person 1 makes the Normative Statement Person 2 makes the Positive Statement 1. The Filibuster is good Because it forces two sides to work together and... |