Just claiming that the consensus of many mental health professionals is untrue is not an argument, nor is randomly determining or tailoring a fallacy from a pre-existing list a valid response. You have the responsibility to offer evidence. Just declaring holes-bolus that you've researched a subject is not sufficient. You also would have to provide your own credentials in the medical field, or at least some background, eg.
I've battled with depression my entire life and I've found the medical community to be woefully misguided. Here's why:
Your also have to determine a flaw in their reasoning, as well as an inherent deception in the claim which you neglect to do. You just simply declare it untrue.
It made me think of the troubadour in Monty Python and the Holy Grail who abuses the cowardly Sir Robin in song and verse, and Sir Robin can only feebly complain: No, I did not. S'not true! Didn't happen that way.
I'm not quite sure where you're headed with your example. Is this your response or their postulation?
'Depression is a medical illness that presents with.......and causes.........'
Which might be an example of a False Cause Fallacy:
False cause
Correlation is when two things occur together. Causation is when one thing causes another thing. To commit the false cause fallacy is to mistake correlation for causation. When A and B occur together, it’s certainly possible that A caused B, but it’s also possible that B caused A. Or that they were both caused by something else. Or that it’s a total coincidence that both A and B have been occurring together.
But without a question or argument it is exactly as Dr. Bo describes it.
Postscript: By way of synchronicity. This discussion by Johan Hari on TED just came through my email:
Johann Hari challenges the way we think about depression
By TED
Author Johann Hari offers a deeply personal and surprisingly uplifting perspective on how to tackle depression. We're doing a TED Interview survey! If you have a few minutes, we'd love to know your thoughts on the show. Find it at surveynerds.com/tedinterview