Appeal to Tradition

argumentum ad antiquitatem

(also known as: appeal to common practice, appeal to antiquity, proof from tradition, appeal to past practice, gadarene swine fallacy [form of], traditional wisdom)

Description: Using historical preferences of the people (tradition), either in general or as specific as the historical preferences of a single individual, as evidence that the historical preference is correct.  Traditions are often passed from generation to generation with no other explanation besides, “this is the way it has always been done”—which is not a reason, it is an absence of a reason.

Logical Form:

We have been doing X for generations.

Therefore, we should keep doing X.

 

Our ancestors thought X was right.

Therefore, X is right.

Example #1:

Dave: For five generations, the men in our family went to Stanford and became doctors, while the women got married and raised children.  Therefore, it is my duty to become a doctor.

Kaitlin: Do you want to become a doctor?

Dave: It doesn’t matter -- it is our family tradition.  Who am I to break it?

Explanation:  Just as it takes people to start traditions, it takes people to end them.  A tradition is not reason for action -- it is like watching the same movie over and over again but never asking why you should keep watching it.

Example #2:

Marriage has traditionally been between a man and a woman; therefore, gay marriage should not be allowed.

Explanation:  Very often traditions stem from religious and/or archaic beliefs, and until people question the logic and reasoning behind such traditions, people who are negatively affected by such traditions will continue to suffer.  Just because it was acceptable in past cultures and times, does not mean it is acceptable today.  Think racism, sexism, slavery, and corporal punishment.

Exception: Victimless traditions that are preserved for the sake of preserving the traditions themselves do not require any other reason.

Tip: If it weren’t for the creativity of our ancestors, we would have no traditions.  Be creative and start your own traditions that somehow make the world a better place.

Variation: The gadarene swine fallacy refers to the metaphor of planes flying in formation.  If one plane appears out of formation, we assume the one plane is wrong, rather than the other planes actually being on the wrong course, but history tells us that at times, the “single planes”, like Martin Luther King, Jr., show us how the rest of us were really just horribly off course.

Comments   

 
-12 #1 D 2013-02-03 15:05
You explained a fallacy using a fallacy. Linking Martin Luther King to a plane was a fallacy in itself
 
 
+14 #2 Bo Bennett 2013-02-03 17:27
What fallacy do you think I have committed there and why?
 

You have no rights to post comments

Visit IsItAFallacy.com! This is the place to ask the community of experts and other fallacyophites (I made up that word) if someone has a committed a fallacy or not. This is a great way to settle a dispute!