Exclusive Premises

(also known as: fallacy of exclusive premises)

Description: A standard form categorical syllogism that has two negative premises either in the form of  “no X are Y” or “some X are not Y”.

Logical Form:

No X are Y.

Some Y are not Z.

Therefore, some Z are not X.

 

No X are Y.

No Y are Z.

Therefore, no Z are X.

Example #1:

No kangaroos are MMA fighters.

Some MMA fighters are not Mormons.

Therefore, some Mormons are not kangaroos.

Example #2:

No animals are insects.

Some insects are not dogs.

Therefore, some dogs are not animals.

Example #3:

No animals are insects.

No insects are dogs.

Therefore, no dogs are animals.

Explanation: Remember why fallacies are so dangerous: because they appear to be good reasoning.  The conclusion in example #1 makes sense, but it does not follow logically -- it is an invalid argument.  Based on the first two premises, there is no way logically to deduce that conclusion.  Now look at examples #2 and #3.  We use the same logical form of the argument, committing the same fallacy, but by changing the terms it is much more clear that something went wrong somewhere, and it did.  This kind of argument, the categorical syllogism, cannot have two negative premises and still be valid.

Just because the conclusion appears true, it does not mean the argument is valid (or strong, in the case of an informal argument).

Exception: None.

Tip: Learn to recognize the forms of formal fallacies, and you will easily spot invalid formal arguments.

Comments   

 
0 #1 Katie 2013-01-11 11:35
A logic beginner here: I would like to see more examples where both of the premises are true and the conclusion is true, but it still is invalid due to exclusive premises. The example in our textbook is this:

No plants are animals.
Some minerals are not animals.
Therefore, some minerals are not plants.

I like how simple your #2 and # 3 syllogisms are.
 

You have no rights to post comments

Visit IsItAFallacy.com! This is the place to ask the community of experts and other fallacyophites (I made up that word) if someone has a committed a fallacy or not. This is a great way to settle a dispute!

Serious about being educated in logical fallacies?  Take the online course at your own pace.