"This is our flag."
Historical archive only. New interaction is disabled.
Original Question
In terms of design (and sometimes symbolism), most U.S. state flags stink. People have been trying to have their respective state flags improved or replaced for decades, but they are almost always shot down.
One argument legislators sometimes use is this:
"THIS is OUR flag!"
In other words, whatever design is currently official - even if it is a state's fifth flag - is "our" flag, even though citizens weren't allowed to vote for it.
It seems to brief to qualify as an argument, but is there an implied fallacy in there? ( This is our flag, therefore we should not change it. )
One possibility is equivocation (I think that's the term), with "our" meaning different things to different people. Another possibility is the suggestion that flags can't or shouldn't be changed, even though they have been changed many times over the years. What fallacy would that be?
Answers
1Right away I am thinking of appeal to tradition . The implied argument is that this is how it has always been therefore this is how it should always be.
Master Logical Fallacies Online
Take the Virversity course and sharpen your reasoning skills with structured lessons.
View Online Course