Athiesm
Historical archive only. New interaction is disabled.
Original Question
Are there any logical fallacies atheists commit when arguing against the existence of God?
Answers
1Oh, absolutely! Just like believers, atheists are humans too, and no human is exempt from the occasional brain flop. Here are a couple of favorite "goofs" that some atheists might make:
1. The "Earth is a smorgasbord and I didn't see God at the buffet line" argument. This is when an atheist declares that because they personally haven't seen evidence of God, He must not exist. But just because you didn't see those delicious meatballs at the buffet doesn't mean they weren't there, you just may not have reached that part of the table yet!
2. The "Aunt Bertha's bad casserole" argument. This is when atheists latch onto the presence of evil in the world as an argument against a loving God. It's like blaming Aunt Bertha because she made a lousy casserole at the family reunion; you can't discount the potential for a good casserole just because of one bad one.
3. Be careful not to confuse the "I don't like greens, so they must not be healthy" argument. This is where an atheist dismisses the idea of God because some aspects of faith make him uncomfortable. Remember, just because you don't like broccoli doesn't mean it's not good for you!
Remember, logic is a two-way street and sometimes it takes a little bit of a sense of humor to navigate it correctly!
1. The "Earth is a smorgasbord and I didn't see God at the buffet line" argument. This is when an atheist declares that because they personally haven't seen evidence of God, He must not exist. But just because you didn't see those delicious meatballs at the buffet doesn't mean they weren't there, you just may not have reached that part of the table yet!
2. The "Aunt Bertha's bad casserole" argument. This is when atheists latch onto the presence of evil in the world as an argument against a loving God. It's like blaming Aunt Bertha because she made a lousy casserole at the family reunion; you can't discount the potential for a good casserole just because of one bad one.
3. Be careful not to confuse the "I don't like greens, so they must not be healthy" argument. This is where an atheist dismisses the idea of God because some aspects of faith make him uncomfortable. Remember, just because you don't like broccoli doesn't mean it's not good for you!
Remember, logic is a two-way street and sometimes it takes a little bit of a sense of humor to navigate it correctly!
Master Logical Fallacies Online
Take the Virversity course and sharpen your reasoning skills with structured lessons.
View Online Course