Discrimination was right because the people I chose were competent.
Historical archive only. New interaction is disabled.
Original Question
If I were to say decide I want to deliberate a ginger hair owned car garage, and then justify this afterward by the fact that they either did a good job and/or were one of the ginger garages known to do a good job, therefore I was not unfairly discriminating against other garages because the people I chose were competent?
Comments on Question
I don't understand the question. It's not discriminatory, illegal or unethical to use a vendor because you like some personal characteristic they have. You don't have to justify it to the vendors you didn't use.
Answers
4If you draw a conclusion based on unsound premises (e.g. that ginger haired owned garages do the best job) then your conclusion is unsound not invalid.
I think, however, you are suggesting something else - that the person prefers to use ginger-haired owned garages (reason unspecified but could be prejudice) and wants others to believe the choice was based on competency and not prejudice.
I think this is a disingenuous use of post hoc rationalization.
If the person continued to exclusively use ginger-haired owned garages because they now believed they had reason to conclude that all g-h owned garages will do a good job then they might be using either the fallacy of composition or hasty generalisation.
Exactly what is the question?
Perhaps post hoc rationalization . In this context, not really a fallacy but more of a biased way of thinking OR a deliberate lie.
I'm not sure what the fallacy name would be, but it it fallacious to assume that a non-ginger person would not be as good as a ginger one.
It's roughly the equivalent of saying "oranges are good, therefore apples are bad".
I'm guessing that would be a non-sequitur (invalid conclusion).
Master Logical Fallacies Online
Take the Virversity course and sharpen your reasoning skills with structured lessons.
View Online Course
Are there actual people who describe car garages based on red-haired people who run it? If so, they're troglodytes.