Is "I'm just doing my job" a fallacy?
Historical archive only. New interaction is disabled.
Original Question
Answers
3I think that is a good example of a fallacy. Whether it be more of an appeal to blind authority or tradition would be based on the reasoning one uses to justify the action beyond the "I'm just doing my job" response (e.g., "I'm just doing what it says to do on this checklist").
There is a legal and psychological aspect to this fallacy as well. It has been called the Nuremberg Defense based on the famous Nuremberg trials after WWII. In the early 60's, psychologist Stanley Milgram wanted to find out if there was more to this phenomenon than just bad people doing bad things. He conducted his famous obedience to authority experiment where he demonstrated that this is more than a reflection of a "bad person," but a psychological phenomenon common to humanity. Today, we would consider this a fallacy (i.e., error in reasoning), but it is one of those errors that is deeply ingrained and difficult to correct.
I didn't know if this would qualify since there is no specific authority referenced in that statement (there aren't any "orders" being followed, per se).
It's almost as if that statement could be used as an example of the Just Because Fallacy when the employee is lazily implying that there should never be an expectation of reasonable policies in the workplace.
For human beings, this explains the survival benefits of tradition, education and faith. One can act intelligently, even if one is not intelligent, by following the orders of a guiding intelligence.
Master Logical Fallacies Online
Take the Virversity course and sharpen your reasoning skills with structured lessons.
View Online Course