Is there any utility in logical fallacies taxonomies?
Historical archive only. New interaction is disabled.
Original Question
Is yes, why? If not, why not?
Answers
1This directly from my book:
There have been many attempts to categorize fallacies, some of which may make fallacies easier to understand. I have chosen to organize all fallacies, alphabetically, by the names for which they are best known. I chose this method because:
...
There is some utility in taxonomy, especially, separating formal fallacies and informal fallacies.
There have been many attempts to categorize fallacies, some of which may make fallacies easier to understand. I have chosen to organize all fallacies, alphabetically, by the names for which they are best known. I chose this method because:
- There is no official taxonomy, nor is there even a taxonomy accepted by the majority of those who classify fallacies.
The ambiguous nature of most of the fallacies means that many of the fallacies can fit in a variety of categories.
Focusing on faux-categorical structures distracts from the fallacies themselves.
...
There is some utility in taxonomy, especially, separating formal fallacies and informal fallacies.
Master Logical Fallacies Online
Take the Virversity course and sharpen your reasoning skills with structured lessons.
View Online Course