← Back to archive

Is this a fallacy? It seems like an attempt to short-circuit Reason...

Historical archive only. New interaction is disabled.

Original Question
I saw this on my news feed, and was curious...

I would definitely NOT trust an aircraft where somebody close to the project was NOT willing to fly on it, but that doesn't mean that I WOULD trust an aircraft because they WERE willing to fly on it:

Answers

1

Quotes are generally a goldmine of fallacies simply based on the fact that they have to be short and are incomplete as far as being an argument, and often taken out of context. In this particular example, we don't exactly know what Branson's intent was, and this would give us some indication of fallaciousness on his part. For example,

"There is no way I would ask others go on Virgin Galactic flight if I didn't feel it was safe enough for myself, therefore you should go on a Virgin Galactic flight."

could be seen as a form of the Appeal to False Authority . If you, the reader, accepted this as a valid reason to go on the plane, you would be guilty of fallacious reasoning, as well.

Based on the quote and the situation, I would have to argue for Branson in that the quote was a more of a reflection of his confidence in his product than an plea for others to accept his authority blindly.

Book

Want the full book?

Get the complete guide to logical fallacies by Bo Bennett.

Buy the Book

Master Logical Fallacies Online

Take the Virversity course and sharpen your reasoning skills with structured lessons.

View Online Course