Proof by Appearance
Historical archive only. New interaction is disabled.
Original Question
Dear Dr. Bo,
I really enjoy parsing through your side and using it as a reference to point out faulty logic when being confronted with the usual gibberish you have in the 'net. When stumbling over this (sorry, german) video
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lBu0Eo3zRl0
where a philosoph tries doing physics and fails miserably, I searched for the fallacie "Proof by Appearance" which basically means the one telling something is coming over so serious, well mannered, perfectly groomed etc. that his argument just HAS to have value. I did not find something in your database and want to ask if it is valuable enough to include it. Incidentially, Terry Pratchett makes great use of this in the figure of Moist von Lipwig.
best regards, Christian
Answers
1This might fit under
proof by intimidation(the "professionalism" can be intimidating)
of even
Note that for this general class of fallacies, the error in reasoning is typically on the part of the viewer who mistakes the professionalism, charm, gibberish, etc. for truth. It would be too presumptions for us to say that the speaker is deliberately trying to trick people—unless we have evidence for this.
Master Logical Fallacies Online
Take the Virversity course and sharpen your reasoning skills with structured lessons.
View Online Course